Matthew Mincone | October 29, 2025 | Car Accident
Surviving a car accident can be a life-altering experience. If you’ve been seriously injured in a car crash, you might have already realized that the accident was just the beginning. Now, you’re facing a lengthy recovery, medical bills, and maybe even lost income.
If your accident was caused by another driver, a car accident lawyer may be able to help you recover compensation. But with so many attorneys to choose from in Tampa, how do you know which one is right for you? Follow this checklist to find the best car accident lawyer for your needs.
1. Start with Experience in Personal Injury Law
Not all lawyers are created equal. Some specialize in family law or criminal defense, while others dedicate their practice to personal injury and car accident cases. When you’ve been injured, you want someone who understands Florida’s traffic laws, insurance requirements, and liability rules inside and out.
Ask how long the attorney has been practicing personal injury law and how many car accident cases they’ve handled. Experience often translates into better case strategy, negotiation skills, and understanding of what your claim is truly worth.
2. Look for Local Knowledge
Hiring a Tampa-based attorney can make a real difference. Local lawyers are familiar with the area’s roadways, common accident locations, and even the tendencies of local courts and insurance adjusters. They’ll know which experts to consult and which doctors specialize in treating auto accident injuries nearby.
A lawyer who practices in your area is also more accessible for meetings and can quickly visit accident scenes or interview witnesses.
3. Check Reviews and Reputation
In today’s world, online reviews are one of the easiest ways to assess a lawyer’s reputation. Look for testimonials on Google, Avvo, and legal directories. Positive reviews that mention communication, compassion, and successful outcomes can be telling signs of a trustworthy attorney.
You can also check the Florida Bar Association website to ensure the lawyer is in good standing and see if they’ve faced any disciplinary actions.
Don’t hesitate to ask for client references or case results—reputable attorneys are proud to share their track record.
4. Ask About Trial Experience
Most car accident claims settle out of court, but sometimes insurance companies refuse to offer fair compensation. In those situations, you’ll want a lawyer who’s ready and willing to take your case to trial.
Ask whether the attorney has tried car accident cases before and what their success rate is in court. A lawyer with strong litigation experience can often negotiate better settlements because insurers know they’re not afraid to fight for clients.
5. Understand the Fee Structure
Almost all Tampa car accident lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing upfront. Instead, your attorney collects a percentage of your settlement or verdict only if they win your case.
Still, it’s smart to clarify details before signing any agreement. Ask what percentage they charge, whether you’ll be responsible for costs if the case isn’t successful, and if there are any hidden fees. Transparency about money is a good indicator of professionalism.
6. Evaluate Communication and Accessibility
When you’re recovering from an accident, you shouldn’t have to chase down your lawyer for updates. During your consultation, pay attention to how quickly they respond to emails or calls. Are they patient in answering your questions? Do they explain legal terms clearly?
A good attorney should make you feel comfortable, respected, and informed throughout your case. Communication is key to a smooth legal process.
7. Make Sure They Have Strong Negotiation Skills
In most car accident cases, reaching a fair settlement depends on how effectively your lawyer can negotiate with insurance companies. Insurers often try to minimize payouts or shift blame onto victims, so having an attorney who knows how to counter lowball offers is essential.
A skilled negotiator understands the tactics insurers use and can present strong evidence to support your claim’s full value. When interviewing potential lawyers, ask about their experience negotiating settlements and how often they’ve been able to secure compensation without going to trial.
Contact Mincone Personal Injury Lawyers for a Free Consultation
Choosing the right car accident lawyer in Tampa can make all the difference in the outcome of your case. By following this checklist, you can feel confident in selecting a lawyer who will protect your rights and handle your case with care.
At Mincone Personal Injury Lawyers, our team is dedicated to helping crash victims rebuild their lives after serious accidents. We combine local experience with personalized attention, ensuring every client receives the guidance and advocacy they deserve.
If you’ve been injured in a Tampa car accident, don’t wait to get the help you need. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us help you take the next step toward recovery.
If you’ve been injured in an accident in Tampa, FL, contact our skilled car accident lawyers at Mincone Personal Injury Lawyers to schedule a free consultation.
We proudly serve Hillsborough County and its surrounding areas:
Mincone Personal Injury Lawyers
1925 E 6th Ave Ste 10
Tampa, FL 33605
(813) 800-0810
Our firm is located near you. We have an office in Tampa
Find us with our GeoCoordinates: 27.9593512,-82.4369179
About The Author
Attorney Matthew Mincone is the founder of Mincone Personal Injury Lawyers. He earned his law degree while attending night programs in New York and is licensed to practice in Florida. With over 15 years of legal experience, Matthew focuses on personal injury cases, including motor vehicle accidents involving cars, commercial trucks, and motorcycles. His commitment to personally handling each case ensures clients receive dedicated representation. Click here to view some of the remarkable case results that Matthew has successfully achieved.
Location: Tampa, FL
